- 23′
SubstitutionLuke O'NienReplaces Omar AldereteSunderland
- 25′
Yellow cardTim IroegbunamEverton
- 43′
GoalMerlin RöhlAssist: Michael KeaneEverton · 1-0
- 47′
Yellow cardJake O'BrienEverton
- 59′
GoalBrian BrobbeyAssist: Enzo Le FéeSunderland · 1-1
- 60′
SubstitutionChemsdine TalbiReplaces Trai HumeSunderland
- 73′
SubstitutionThierno BarryReplaces BetoEverton
- 73′
SubstitutionTyrique GeorgeReplaces Tim IroegbunamEverton
- 77′
SubstitutionHabib DiarraReplaces Noah SadikiSunderland
- 77′
SubstitutionWilson IsidorReplaces Brian BrobbeySunderland
- 77′
SubstitutionChris RiggReplaces Nilson AnguloSunderland
- 81′
GoalEnzo Le FéeAssist: Chris RiggSunderland · 1-2
- 88′
SubstitutionSéamus ColemanReplaces Jake O'BrienEverton
- 88′
SubstitutionDwight McNeilReplaces Merlin RöhlEverton
- 90+1′
GoalWilson IsidorAssist: Habib DiarraSunderland · 1-3
- 90+6′
Yellow cardJames GarnerEverton